The I'M TIC TOC TINT LIP CASHMERE in 008muddy red color by I'M MEME proved to be a delightful surprise, according to Nia's video review. Nia, with a medium light olive skin tone, found the deep brick red shade to be her favorite red to wear. The lip tint's matte finish added to its appeal. Nia compared it to the Lip Maestro, which had a burnt red shade, and the YSL Lip Couture, both of which had a glossier finish. Overall, Nia thoroughly enjoyed using this lip tint, highlighting its pleasant surprise and matte texture. However, it would have been beneficial to include more information about the product's longevity and application.